Vendors & EquipmentUlaVulcanBe 4Blue Origin

ULA pins Vulcan failure on fuel supply, not BE-4 engines

ULA's preliminary report blames inadequate fuel supply to BE-4 engines for the November 15 Vulcan failure that lost 40 Amazon Leo satellites, sparing Blue Origin's New Glenn a redesign.

3 min read

ULA failure: “Fuel supply problem”Vendors & Equipment
ULA failure: “Fuel supply problem”Nikita Kulikov / unsplash

Why it matters

  • November 15 Vulcan failure destroyed 40 Amazon Leo satellites
  • ULA preliminary finding: inadequate fuel supply to BE-4 engines, not engine performance
  • BE-4 engines and Centaur CL-V upper stage both performed nominally
  • FAA investigation with ULA continues into definitive cause
  • Blue Origin's New Glenn January 2027 launch target appears less at risk

The story

United Launch Alliance says inadequate fuel supply to its BE-4 engines, not the engines themselves, caused the November 15 Vulcan rocket failure that destroyed 40 Amazon Leo satellites.

The preliminary report, released this week, narrows what had been a wider field of suspicion. Investigators had considered two candidates: a defect in the BE-4 engines supplied by Blue Origin, or a failure of the rocket's Centaur CL-V upper stage. Neither appears at fault.

ULA is still working with the Federal Aviation Administration to determine the definitive cause. Its statement says preliminary indications point to low booster thrust resulting from an inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from engine performance. Everything else worked nominally, the company reiterated.

What worked and what failed?

The second stage and its RL10 engines come out of the preliminary assessment clean.

"As shared previously, the Vulcan second stage appears to have started nominally, and the RL10 engines were operating as planned. The second stage was performing well but was unable to recover from the performance loss resulting in loss of mission. All indications are that the solid rocket booster performance was nominal, following nozzle improvements implemented for this launch," the ULA statement said.

Astrophysicist Jonathan McDowell summarised the finding: "[The] first stage failure was due to a problem in the fuel supply from the tanks to the engines, not in the BE-4 engines themselves. The BE-4s worked ok (good news for New Glenn), as did the Centaur CV-L."

Why does this matter for Blue Origin?

A common BE-4 defect would have had consequences well beyond ULA. Blue Origin's own New Glenn rocket flies the same engine family, and a shared fault could have forced additional redesign, testing and qualification work, threatening New Glenn's return-to-flight schedule. That risk has now diminished substantially, according to the preliminary finding.

Dave Limp, CEO of Blue Origin, said: "Sunday's outcome was disappointing for everyone involved. In these moments, it's important to have strong industry partnerships. I'm proud of the BE-4 team for their rapid response and support of ULA's investigation. We're confident in the team at ULA and look forward to Vulcan's return to flight."

What does this change for the US launch market?

The near-term picture stays tight. With ULA's Atlas V retired and the Vulcan-powered rocket grounded under FAA investigation, almost the entire US launch burden now falls back onto SpaceX, with Blue Origin second in line.

For AST SpaceMobile, which is awaiting launches on New Glenn, the preliminary outcome is close to the best available result. New Glenn's January 2027 launch target remains subject to other constraints, but the prospect of the Vulcan failure triggering another major BE-4 setback has materially diminished.

For Amazon, the loss of 40 Leo satellites adds to the long queue of its broadband constellation awaiting rides to orbit, at a moment when certified US launch capacity is concentrated in a single provider. ULA's path back to the pad depends on the FAA investigation confirming the fuel-supply finding and clearing a fix.

Also reported

Share this article:

« PreviousNext »

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

560 articles