Spectrum & PolicyFccDanielle Thumann SeversSenate ConfirmationFcc Independence

Senate Vote Set for Nov. 18 on FCC Nominee Thumann Severs

The Senate will vote Nov. 18 on Danielle Thumann Severs, Carr's legal advisor, giving Republicans a 3-1 FCC majority amid fights over broadcaster licensing.

3 min read

Cruz Schedules Confirmation Vote for FCC Commissioner Nominee Thumann-SeversSpectrum & Policy
Cruz Schedules Confirmation Vote for FCC Commissioner Nominee Thumann-Seversbones64 / pixabay

Why it matters

  • Senate vote on FCC nominee Danielle Thumann Severs scheduled for Nov. 18
  • Confirmation would give Republicans a 3-1 majority on a five-seat commission
  • Roughly three quarters of questions at the nearly two-hour hearing went to Thumann Severs
  • CPJ called for bipartisan FCC nominees ahead of the vote
  • Thumann Severs committed to Cruz that licensing decisions would rest on law and record

The story

Senator Ted Cruz, Republican of Texas, has scheduled a Senate vote for November 18 to confirm Danielle Thumann Severs as the fourth commissioner of the Federal Communications Commission.

If approved, Thumann Severs would give Republicans a 3-1 advantage on a commission that normally seats five members. Anna Gomez would remain the sole Democratic commissioner. The party balance matters because commission votes drive spectrum policy, licensing decisions and enforcement actions across the US communications sector.

Thumann Severs currently serves as senior legal advisor to FCC Chairman Brendan Carr. She appeared Tuesday before the Senate Commerce Committee, one of four nominees at a hearing that ran nearly two hours. Roughly three quarters of the questions were directed at her.

The session was contentious. Democratic members accused her of avoiding their questions. She hesitated when pressed on accusations that Carr has overreached his authority against broadcasters' First Amendment rights, responding instead with a commitment to ensure broadcasters act "in the public interest." That answer did not satisfy Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts.

What does this change for the FCC's independence?

Democrats on the committee are worried about more than one nominee's answers. A recent Supreme Court decision on presidential authority over executive departments, they argued, could allow President Trump to fire Commissioner Gomez outright. They lobbied to have Gomez appear at the same hearing. The request was denied.

The Committee to Protect Journalists amplified that concern on Wednesday, calling for bipartisan FCC nominees.

"Americans trust the Federal Communications Commission to act as an independent, bipartisan agency that upholds the First Amendment," said José Zamora, CPJ's regional director for the Americas. "The Senate must ensure the FCC upholds that trust by not allowing a partisan nomination to move forward."

For broadcasters and network operators, the stakes are concrete. The FCC licenses stations, approves transfers and polices the airwaves. A commissioner who declines to constrain the chairman on licensing questions changes the risk calculus for every license holder.

Where does Cruz stand on Carr's broadcaster probes?

Cruz himself has broken with his party's chairman on at least one high-profile case. He criticized Carr's call to investigate ABC's broadcast licenses after late night host Jimmy Kimmel joked about Melania Trump on air earlier this year.

"It is not government's job to censor speech, and I do not believe the FCC should operate as the speech police," Cruz told Punchbowl News in late April.

At Tuesday's hearing, Cruz, who chairs the committee, cited the ABC investigation alongside numerous instances of Democratic presidents threatening investigations into broadcasters over content they disliked. He then put a direct question to the nominee.

"If you are confirmed, will you commit to basing licensing decisions on the law and the record, and to not using the FCC's authority to pressure or punish a broadcaster for protected speech?" Cruz asked. Thumann Severs replied: "yes."

What happens next?

The November 18 vote is the decisive step. Confirmation would restore the commission to four seats, still one short of its statutory five, and settle the partisan balance at 3-1 until a fifth nominee emerges. A vacancy for the Democratic side, or a dismissal of Gomez under the Supreme Court's new reading of presidential authority, would leave the agency without a Democratic voice at all — a scenario CPJ and Senate Democrats have now put on the record before the vote.

Also reported

Share this article:

« PreviousNext »

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

499 articles