Spectrum & PolicyFccBrendan CarrDanielle ThumannBen Ray Lujan
Luján Warns Carr Has 'Three or Four Months' Left as FCC Chairman
Sen. Ben Ray Luján says FCC Chairman Brendan Carr has 'three or four months' before Democratic control brings monthly oversight hearings on the commission.
Spectrum & PolicyWhy it matters
- Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-N.M.) predicted Carr will face monthly Senate and House hearings once Democrats hold the gavels.
- The hearing covered Danielle Thumann's nomination as the third Republican FCC commissioner.
- The FCC currently operates with a 2–1 Republican majority; three commissioners are needed for a quorum.
- Committee Chairman Ted Cruz cited the FCC probe of eight ABC-owned stations after Carr's threat over 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!'.
- Democrats demanded the hearing also cover Commissioner Anna Gomez's renomination; a Supreme Court ruling could allow her dismissal.
The story
Federal Communications Commission Chairman Brendan Carr has, in one Democratic senator's estimate, no more than three or four months left as an unaccountable agency head. Sen. Ben Ray Luján of New Mexico issued that timeline during a Senate Commerce Committee hearing on the nomination of Carr's legal adviser, Danielle Thumann, to serve as the third Republican FCC commissioner.
"I don't think Chairman Carr is going to be around more than another three or four months, because when we have the gavels in here, he will be here once a month," Luján said. He warned that Carr would be summoned before the Senate monthly, and before the House as well, once Democrats hold committee chairs.
The hearing was among the first held since Democrats regained control of both the House and Senate in the midterm elections one week earlier. It served as an early signal of how the new majority will treat the five-member commission and the broadcast sector it regulates.
Why was the hearing itself controversial?
Democrats repeatedly objected to considering Thumann alone. They argued her hearing should have been paired with a renomination hearing for Commissioner Anna Gomez, the sole Democrat on the FCC, which requires five members at full strength.
"I strongly believe we should be considering the renomination of Commissioner Anna Gomez, the sole remaining Democrat," said Sen. John Hickenlooper of Colorado. "She is someone I have supported and is serving on an expired term."
Hickenlooper noted that FCC rules require a minimum of three commissioners for a quorum. Gomez's presence in the current 2–1 Republican majority is therefore necessary for the agency to conduct business. He added that a recent Supreme Court decision could let President Trump fire Gomez outright, which would leave the commission with no Democratic representation at all.
"I don't think that today's nomination is moving on its own by coincidence, and I don't think this strategy will age well in a new Congress or a new administration," Hickenlooper said.
Sen. Ed Markey of Massachusetts went further. "We should be investigating the FCC, not confirming a Brendan Carr adviser to the commission," he said. He called for confirming Gomez and filling the other vacant Democratic seat alongside any Republican nominee.
What did the nominee say?
Thumann testified that, if confirmed, she would focus on modernizing America's communications networks, strengthening public safety and fighting consumer fraud.
"Protecting consumers from illegal robocalls and fraud and scams must remain the agency's top consumer protection priority," she told the committee.
She has advised Carr on and off for several years, covering matters before the Wireline Bureau, the Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau, and the Consumer and Governmental Affairs Bureau.
How did First Amendment questions play out?
The sharpest exchanges concerned Carr's posture toward broadcasters rather than Thumann's record. Asked by Markey whether the FCC can punish a broadcaster because the president dislikes its coverage, Thumann gave an indirect answer. Broadcasters hold licenses under a public-trustee model with public-interest obligations, she said, and the FCC is charged with enforcing that standard.
Markey called the question a straightforward constitutional matter. "The FCC cannot punish a broadcaster simply because the president doesn't like its coverage," he said. "Yet Chairman Carr, your boss right now, has threatened to do exactly that."
Committee Chairman Sen. Ted Cruz, a Texas Republican, took the opposite view. He cited instances of Democratic presidents threatening broadcast investigations and referenced the commission's probe of eight ABC-owned stations, opened after Carr threatened the network over an episode of "Jimmy Kimmel Live!" Cruz asked whether Thumann would commit to basing licensing decisions on the law and the record, without using FCC authority to pressure broadcasters over protected speech. She replied with one word: "Yes."
Luján closed with a personal warning. Reflecting on his own vote to approve Carr as chairman, he said he no longer recognizes the commissioner Carr has become. Addressing Thumann directly, he urged her not to let the president and the chairman diminish her or her future in policy, and to keep the FCC "a full, independent body."
With Democrats taking the gavels in January, Carr should expect monthly testimony in the Senate and House, and the Thumann and Gomez nominations will test whether the commission returns to full, bipartisan strength in the new Congress.
Also reported
Source: tvtechnology.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.
536 articles