Spectrum & PolicyE RateFccUniversal Service FundUniversal Service Policy

FCC Nominee Refuses to Commit on E-Rate Future in Senate Hearing

FCC nominee Danielle Thumann Severs declined to say whether the agency can eliminate E-Rate, the $2.5 billion-a-year subsidy for schools and libraries, at a November 10 Senate hearing.

3 min read

Senate Democrats grill FCC nominee on E-Rate's futureSpectrum & Policy
Senate Democrats grill FCC nominee on E-Rate's futurePexels / pixabay

Why it matters

  • FCC nominee Danielle Thumann Severs declined on November 10 to say whether the FCC can sunset E-Rate, a roughly $2.5 billion/year USF program.
  • Severs acknowledged Section 254 of the Telecommunications Act explicitly requires a discount mechanism for schools and libraries.
  • Senator Ted Cruz sought a commitment to review all four USF programs; Severs agreed a 'top-to-bottom review' is important.
  • Confirmation must occur before Democrats take control of Congress in January; Commissioner Anna Gomez is in holdover status through 2027.

The story

The Republican nominee for FCC Commissioner, Danielle Thumann Severs, on Tuesday refused to say whether the Commission has the authority to eliminate E-Rate, the roughly $2.5 billion-a-year program that subsidizes telecom services for schools and libraries across the United States.

Severs, nominated by President Trump in August to serve as the third Republican commissioner, appeared before a Senate hearing on November 10 that started an hour late and lasted just one hour. The FCC currently seats two Republicans and one Democrat. Democrats posed most of the questions during the uncharacteristically short session, held alongside nominees to other agencies.

What does this change for schools and libraries?

The FCC has an open proceeding that could change or eliminate E-Rate, part of the Universal Service Fund. Dozens of schools and libraries have told the FCC the program is essential to their functioning.

Pressed by multiple Democrats on the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee, Severs — who currently serves as senior counsel to FCC Chairman Brendan Carr — repeatedly declined to take a position. She said she did not want to "prejudge the open proceeding at the FCC."

Asked directly whether the FCC has authority to sunset the program, she did not answer. She instead acknowledged that Section 254 of the Telecommunications Act "explicitly" requires the FCC to "have a discount mechanism in place to ensure that these services are available at comparable costs to schools and libraries."

"In the event that there are changes that we make to the program, we should be very mindful of that statutory authority," she added.

She also avoided questions about Chairman Carr's use of the Commission against broadcasters and comedians, an issue Democrats raised during the session.

Republican questions point to a broader USF review

Among the few Republicans who questioned the nominee, Senator Ted Cruz of Texas asked whether she would "commit to a rigorous review of all four USF programs to identify and root out waste, fraud and abuse" and "oppose any expansion of the fund beyond its current scope."

On that point, Severs was more forthcoming.

"I think it's incredibly important that we be doing a top-to-bottom review of all of the programs," she said, pointing to the E-Rate proceeding already in progress.

The exchange signals where the substantive fight over universal service policy will run if her confirmation succeeds: Republicans want a cost-cutting audit of all four USF programs, while Democrats want to preserve E-Rate as a statutory obligation.

A nomination racing the calendar

No date is set for a Senate vote on Severs. If Republicans intend to confirm her, they must act before Democrats take control of Congress in January.

Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts, who won reelection last week, reiterated his opposition and called for two Democrats to be nominated alongside her.

"My own opinion is that we should not proceed with this nomination at this time, and we should also ensure that two Democrats are confirmed to the Commission," Markey said. "If we are going to confirm an additional Republican, we should not wind up with the absurd position of having, by the end of next year, three Republicans and no Democrats on the Commission. I don't think that serves the public interest."

House Democrats made a parallel appeal in a recent letter, urging the renomination of Commissioner Anna Gomez, who is serving in a holdover capacity through the end of 2027 after her term expired in June.

The E-Rate proceeding remains open at the FCC, and the nominee's confirmation timeline — squeezed between the lame-duck session and the January changeover — will determine whether the program's fate is decided by a 2-1 or a 3-1 Commission.

Also reported

Share this article:

« PreviousNext »

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

499 articles