Spectrum & PolicyTelkom South AfricaStarlinkIcasaB Bbee
Telkom urges ICASA to ease BEE rules for Starlink and rivals alike
Telkom asks ICASA to drop 30% BEE ownership rules for all licensees, including Starlink — if easing applies equally to incumbents and satellite newcomers.
Spectrum & PolicyWhy it matters
- Telkom's filing to ICASA challenges 2021 rules requiring 30% ownership by historically disadvantaged groups plus Level 4 B-BBEE status.
- Communications Minister Solly Malatsi issued a policy direction in December 2025 pushing ICASA to align with the B-BBEE framework.
- Telkom names Starlink, Amazon Leo, Spacesail, Eutelsat OneWeb and Avanti as prospective satellite entrants.
- Starlink has refused to cede the required 30% ownership stake, keeping it out of South Africa.
The story
Telkom South Africa has formally asked regulator ICASA to scrap or soften its 2021 equity ownership rules — the 30% historically disadvantaged ownership requirement that has kept Starlink out of the country — provided any easing applies equally to incumbents and new satellite entrants.
The submission, filed to ICASA's inquiry on new individual electronic communications network service (I-ECNS) licences, targets two specific conditions: the requirement that licensees be at least 30% owned by historically disadvantaged groups, and the demand for Level 4 B-BBEE status. Telkom argues both go beyond what the B-BBEE Act and the ICT sector codes actually require.
That is a notable argument from the country's partly state-owned fixed-line operator. Telkom says the rules create regulatory uncertainty, raise costs and may already have deterred network investment in South Africa. The claim is plausible on its face — investors dislike ambiguity — but Telkom offers no investment figure to substantiate it, and the filing itself acknowledges no specific delayed project.
What does Telkom want instead?
Telkom states it still supports the country's empowerment goals. What it objects to is the mechanism. Its proposed alternatives:
- skills development programmes
- local supply chain commitments
- infrastructure investment
- equity-equivalent investment programmes
In other words, contribution measured in spending and capability rather than shareholding. Whether ICASA accepts equity-equivalents as a substitute for direct ownership is the operative question, and the submission does not address how compliance would be audited.
Why this matters for Starlink
The filing lands amid a live policy fight. Communications Minister Solly Malatsi issued a policy direction in December 2025 instructing ICASA to align its licensing framework with the B-BBEE framework — a move widely read in South Africa as clearing a path for Starlink, which has consistently refused to cede the required 30% ownership stake.
Telkom cites that ministerial direction in its own submission. But it adds a condition that sharpens the story: any relaxation must cover existing operators as well as newcomers. Telkom names the satellite players it expects to enter — Starlink, Amazon Leo, Spacesail, Eutelsat OneWeb and Avanti — and insists new satellite operators seeking licences must meet the same terms and social obligations as current licensees.
The concern is explicit: without parity, South Africa risks a dual regulatory regime in which incumbent operators carry obligations that low-orbit entrants escape. A foreign constellation paying equity-equivalent fees into skills programmes would compete against terrestrial operators still bound by ownership rules ICASA itself may have deemed excessive.
The caveat inside the concession
There is an obvious self-interest here. Telkom competes — or would compete — with satellite broadband for connectivity revenue, particularly in underserved regions where fixed-line coverage is thin. Arguing for equal treatment of entrants is also arguing that entrants not get a cheaper door in. Skepticism cuts both ways: Telkom's cost-and-uncertainty critique of the 2021 rules may be sound, but the remedy it proposes happens to level a playing field tilted toward its own position.
What remains unsaid in the submission is equally telling. Telkom does not quantify the alleged investment chill. It does not specify what Level 4 B-BBEE status costs licensees annually. And it does not say whether it would itself relinquish existing empowerment credentials in exchange for the flexible options it proposes.
What happens next
ICASA's inquiry continues, and the regulator must now weigh the minister's December 2025 direction against objections from empowerment advocates and the licensing terms Telkom wants rewritten for everyone. If ICASA adopts uniform, more flexible equity rules, Starlink's South African launch — blocked to date by the 30% ownership demand — could follow quickly; if it preserves ownership requirements for incumbents only, Telkom's dual-regime warning becomes the industry's next dispute.
Also reported
Source: Advanced Television
More from Rebecca Stone
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.
521 articles