Spectrum & PolicyFederal Communications CommissionDanielle Thumann SeversU S SenateMedia Policy

Senate Panel Confirms Thumann Severs, Giving FCC a 3-1 Republican Majority

Senate Commerce confirmed Danielle Thumann Severs as the FCC's third Republican commissioner in a vote Democrats boycotted, citing FOIA records they say show false testimony.

3 min read

Senate Commerce Committee Approves Thumann Severs for FCC CommissionerSpectrum & Policy
Senate Commerce Committee Approves Thumann Severs for FCC Commissionerjensjunge / pixabay

Why it matters

  • Senate Commerce Committee approved Danielle Thumann Severs today, making the FCC 3-1 Republican.
  • All Democratic members boycotted the vote after Chairman Ted Cruz refused a delay.
  • Protect Democracy FOIA records, reported by Politico, allegedly show she worked with Chair Brendan Carr on media issues despite denying it under oath.
  • Records reportedly tie her to Skydance-Paramount merger commitments, 60 Minutes complaints and the Jimmy Kimmel controversy.
  • The FCC normally has five commissioners; one seat remains vacant.

The story

The Senate Commerce Committee voted today to approve Danielle Thumann Severs as the third Republican commissioner on the Federal Communications Commission, moving the agency to a 3-1 Republican majority. Not a single Democrat on the committee attended the session.

Every Democratic member boycotted the meeting. They had asked Chairman Ted Cruz (R-Texas) to delay the vote. Cruz did not.

The boycott drew a sharp rebuke from Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio), who called the absent Democrats "sons of bitches" and described their conduct as a "total disgrace."

"The Democrat members of this committee are total and complete childish temper tantrum. For the second time, decide not to show up for work," Moreno said. "Ask yourself at home: If you're at home, are you able just to not show up for work because you want to take your toys home and be upset."

Moreno also turned on voters who backed Democrats in January, when the party took control of the House and the Senate.

"For those of you who voted for Democrats, what did you vote for? Did you vote for people who didn't show up to work?" he said. "Did you vote for people who aren't willing to defend this country. Did you vote for Democrats that want to shut down this government while they still get paid for people who have every meal taken care of for them?"

What does the dispute turn on?

The boycott was not procedural theater alone. Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-Wash.), a committee member sharply critical of FCC leadership during Thumann Severs's confirmation hearing, had asked Cruz to pull the nomination from Wednesday's executive session and hold a second hearing.

His request cited findings from the group Protect Democracy, obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests and reported by Politico the day before the vote. Luján argued the records proved Thumann Severs gave false testimony at her confirmation hearing, where she told senators she had not worked with FCC Chairman Brendan Carr on "any media-related issues."

Protect Democracy asserts the records show the opposite. According to the group, Thumann Severs:

  • was directly involved in drafting Skydance's commitments ahead of FCC approval of its merger with Paramount;
  • processed complaints related to CBS's "60 Minutes";
  • coordinated the FCC's response to the Jimmy Kimmel controversy.

Rachel Goodman, special counsel at Protect Democracy, issued a direct warning to senators before any confirmation vote. "For nearly two years, the Trump administration has weaponized the FCC to suppress journalism and speech that the President dislikes," Goodman said. "Before voting to confirm any new FCC Commissioner, Senators must ensure that the nominee will not continue that agenda."

The FCC, which normally seats five commissioners, now operates with four: three Republicans and one Democrat. Thumann Severs's approval consolidates Republican control of an agency that has sat at the center of contested media-policy decisions, including the Paramount-Skydance merger conditions and the commission's handling of broadcast complaints.

The nomination now moves to the full Senate, where Republicans hold a majority following January's chamber takeover. A final confirmation vote would complete the FCC's Republican bench at four seats pending any nomination for the remaining vacancy.

Also reported

Share this article:

« Previous

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

545 articles