Spectrum & PolicyBroadband PermittingPermitting ReformUniversal Service FundRural Broadband

USTelecom tells new Congress: 'Let us build' as broadband permits take 270 days

USTelecom CEO Jonathan Spalter urged the new Congress to 'let us build,' citing 270-day federal broadband permit delays and a court ruling that clouds the Universal Service Fund.

4 min read

USTelecom to new Congress: Let us buildSpectrum & Policy
USTelecom to new Congress: Let us buildJerboa_in_the_air / pixabay

Why it matters

  • Federal broadband permits average 270 days versus 50-60 days for movie filming permits on federal land, per USTelecom CEO Jonathan Spalter.
  • The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, excluding some broadband projects from NEPA review, awaits a Senate floor vote expected before Thanksgiving.
  • Delaware Governor Matt Meyer's January executive order set a 120-day permit review shot clock for broadband and priority projects.
  • The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the FCC lacked authority to create USAC, the body administering the multibillion-dollar Universal Service Fund.
  • FCC Commissioner Olivia Trusty urged continuation of the bipartisan congressional USF working group in the new year.

The story

A federal broadband permit takes an average of 270 days to secure, while a permit to film a movie on federal land takes 50 to 60 days. That is nearly nine months of delay per approval, and USTelecom wants the incoming Congress to end it.

"You know that on federal land, the average permit to film a movie is about 50 to 60 days, but to get a broadband permit, it takes an average of 270 days. We can do better," USTelecom CEO Jonathan Spalter told attendees at the organization's Connectivity Forum in Washington, DC, on Tuesday, November 17.

Spalter issued a three-word directive to the new Congress: "Let us build."

What changes with the new Congress?

The broadband industry intends to keep pressing for federal permitting reform in the new year. Democrats will control both chambers of Congress, while President Trump remains in the White House. Spalter sees an opening in that split.

"I'm more optimistic that we can actually have progress on such a deeply bipartisan issue as broadband ... both the Democratic and the Republican sides of the aisle are motivated and incentivized to make progress," he said in a recent conversation with Light Reading.

One concrete vehicle already exists. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) is advancing in the Senate with industry support. The bill would exclude a range of federally supported broadband projects from National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) review. A committee has voted it out, and a floor vote is expected before Thanksgiving next week. The bill still lacks a companion in the House, and environmental and tribal organizations have opposed it vocally.

What is happening at the state level?

Delaware offers the model USTelecom wants other states to copy. Governor Matt Meyer, a Democrat, signed an executive order in January streamlining state permitting regulations under his "JobsFirst" initiative. The order implements a 120-day shot clock for reviewing permit applications and provides a single point of contact within the government for priority projects.

Melissa Mann, chief public policy officer at Lumen, wants that model exported. She said she would like to take the governor on a "roadshow to multiple states" to share what he has implemented.

"We can do a lot at the federal level when it comes to permitting, but so often when you're building these networks, it's municipality by municipality," Mann said during a panel at the forum.

The message for network planners is direct. Federal reform may accelerate, but the binding constraint on rollout schedules remains local review timelines in most markets.

Why is the Universal Service Fund under pressure?

Permitting is not the only item on USTelecom's congressional agenda. The industry group also wants Congress to shore up the Universal Service Fund (USF), which supports billions of dollars in annual programs designed to keep broadband networks affordable and sustainable, particularly in rural areas.

The fund's legal foundation is now unstable. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals recently ruled that the FCC lacks the legal authority to create the Universal Service Administration Company (USAC), the entity that administers the federal USF.

"A recent court decision in the Fifth Circuit put a cloud over the administration of the Universal Service Fund," Spalter told forum attendees. "Congress should reaffirm USAC's authority to administer the Universal Service Fund, and we think it can do it with very targeted, laser-focused language."

What is the FCC's position?

Republican FCC Commissioner Olivia Trusty, another speaker at Tuesday's forum, indicated the FCC will continue its own reforms of USF programs. The commission under Chairman Brendan Carr has largely sought to cut several of those programs, proposing new barriers to the low-income Lifeline subsidy program and opening a proceeding that could end the E-Rate fund for schools and libraries.

Trusty said the FCC must "continue to work to be good stewards of the fund." She expressed hope that Congress, the FCC and industry can work together on what comes next.

"I do hope within the new year that the work of the bipartisan, bicameral, congressional USF working group continues because their success is really key to restoring the long-term certainty of the universal service program," Trusty said.

The coming months will test both tracks: a possible Senate floor vote on BAAJA before Thanksgiving, and a congressional USF working group whose output could determine the fate of rural broadband subsidies.

Also reported

Share this article:

« PreviousNext »

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

582 articles