Carriers & OperatorsT MobileAffordable Broadband ActData CapsNew York
T-Mobile must scrap data caps on $15 New York broadband plans
New York's OAG found T-Mobile throttled low-income broadband customers to 650 Kbps after 50GB. Caps must go within 120 days.
Carriers & OperatorsWhy it matters
- T-Mobile throttled $15/month ABA plan customers by over 97%, to 650 Kbps, after 50GB — reachable in about four days.
- Under the November 9 Assurance of Discontinuance, T-Mobile must drop data caps and extend ABA plans network-wide within 120 days.
- T-Mobile hid its ABA page from search engines and must make it discoverable within 60 days.
- The ABA, effective January 2025 after a 2024 federal appeals court win, requires $15/25Mbit/s or $20/200Mbit/s plans.
- A 300-day compliance report must disclose ABA enrollment and average download speeds; violations can draw $1,000 civil penalties.
The story
T-Mobile must remove data caps from its low-income New York broadband plans within 120 days after the state's Office of the Attorney General (OAG) found the operator throttled Affordable Broadband Act (ABA) customers by more than 97% — from 25 Mbit/s down to 650 Kbps — once they hit 50GB of monthly usage.
A typical customer on the $15/month plan reached that cap after roughly four days, the OAG said in a press release. The ABA, passed in 2021 and effective January 2025, requires ISPs to offer low-income households either a $15/month plan at 25 Mbit/s or a $20/month plan at 200 Mbit/s. T-Mobile offered the $15 tier. It just didn't offer the speeds for very long.
The OAG's findings go beyond throttling. Investigators said T-Mobile only sold ABA plans where it had 5G coverage, "even though it offered full-price internet plans that could deliver 25 Mbps download speeds in areas where it had 4G service." The law, in other words, applied to some of its network and not the parts where full-price customers lived.
Then there was the website. The ABA requires providers to make "reasonable efforts" to promote their affordable plans. Instead, the OAG found T-Mobile "specifically coded its website to hide its ABA plan information from search engines, making it difficult for New Yorkers searching for low-priced internet to find their plans." SEO, deployed in reverse.
What did T-Mobile agree to?
The settlement came via an Assurance of Discontinuance published November 9, triggered by a concern the New York Department of Public Service raised with the OAG in June 2025. T-Mobile "cooperated with the OAG's investigation" and, while it "neither admits nor denies" the findings, has committed to:
- Removing data caps from its ABA plans within 120 days
- Offering ABA plans everywhere it sells fixed wireless home internet, within 120 days
- Making its ABA webpage discoverable by search engines within 60 days
- Filing a compliance report with the OAG within 300 days, certifying the fixes and disclosing enrolled subscriber numbers and their average download speeds
Compliance absolves T-Mobile this time. But the ABA allows civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation, and the assurance states plainly that the OAG "may initiate a subsequent investigation, civil action, or proceeding to enforce this Assurance, for violations of the Assurance, or if the Assurance is voided." The door stays open.
Does anyone know if the law works?
Context matters here. The ABA passed in 2021 during the pandemic, then spent years stuck in court challenges from ISP groups including CTIA and USTelecom — both of which count T-Mobile among their members. A federal appeals court upheld the law in 2024, and it took effect in January 2025.
Nearly two years in, its actual impact is hard to measure. An April analysis by the Benton Institute for Broadband & Society, based on the first annual compliance reports (due each November 15), found that several providers — T-Mobile, Charter, Optimum and Verizon — concealed subscriber numbers as confidential, which New York law permits. T-Mobile withheld most of its information, including "a description of procedures for verifying consumer eligibility."
That leaves what Benton called "no meaningful opportunity to learn if the law is making a material difference in the lives of New Yorkers, nor to target outreach to those who the benefits have not reached." Other states, the report added, can't "draw any evidence-based conclusions about the relative merits of mandating that ISPs provide affordable broadband plans."
T-Mobile's mandated 300-day report — with enrollment counts and real average speeds — may finally force some of that data into the open. The second annual batch of compliance reports lands November 15. For an industry that failed to kill the law in court, obscurity is the next best strategy. New York has just made it slightly harder to maintain.
Also reported
Original: ag.ny.gov
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
News editor covering technology and product news in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.
536 articles