Spectrum & PolicyT MobileNew YorkAffordable Broadband ActLow Income Broadband

New York Hits T-Mobile With First Enforcement Over Low-Income Data Caps

New York AG Letitia James took the first Affordable Broadband Act enforcement action against T-Mobile over data caps that throttled low-income users by 97 percent.

2 min read

New York Blocks T-Mobile Data Caps Under Affordable Broadband ActSpectrum & Policy
New York Blocks T-Mobile Data Caps Under Affordable Broadband Actgeralt / pixabay

Why it matters

  • New York AG Letitia James announced the state's first enforcement action under the Affordable Broadband Act on November 10, 2026.
  • T-Mobile allegedly placed data caps on low-income plans in violation of the law.
  • Average subscribers had speeds throttled by 97 percent after about four days, the state said.

The story

New York Attorney General Letitia James announced Monday the first enforcement action against an internet service provider under the state's Affordable Broadband Act, and the target is T-Mobile.

The allegation is stark. The state says T-Mobile placed data caps on its low-income plans in violation of the law. The average subscriber saw speeds throttled by 97 percent after roughly four days of use, according to the attorney general's office.

That figure carries the story. A 97 percent speed reduction does not slow a connection incrementally; it reduces a broadband line to something close to unusable for streaming, work calls, or school applications. For households enrolled in a low-income plan, the throttle arrived less than a week into each billing cycle.

The action, announced on November 10, 2026, marks the first time the New York attorney general's office has enforced the Affordable Broadband Act against an ISP since the law took effect. James said Monday that T-Mobile had instituted data caps on its low-income plans in violation of the statute.

What does the Affordable Broadband Act require?

The law obliges internet providers operating in New York to offer affordable broadband service to low-income households. Data caps and aggressive throttling on the discounted plans sit in direct tension with that obligation, which is the core of the state's complaint against T-Mobile.

Monday's announcement came jointly from Governor Kathy Hochul's office and Attorney General James, framed as an effort to improve access to affordable home internet for vulnerable New Yorkers.

Why the first case matters

First enforcement actions set the practical boundaries of a statute. Until this week, the Affordable Broadband Act existed largely on paper for providers, defining obligations without tested consequences. By singling out T-Mobile's throttling practices, the attorney general has signaled that usage limits on low-income tiers will be treated as violations rather than pricing discretion.

The complaint's specifics give the case its weight. Regulators did not allege technical network management; they documented that average subscribers on the affected plans lost nearly all of their usable speed after about four days, a pattern the state treats as an unlawful data cap.

For T-Mobile, the enforcement action puts its low-income broadband business in New York under direct regulatory scrutiny. The company now faces pressure to remove the caps and bring its discounted plans into compliance with state law.

Other carriers offering similar discounted plans in New York will be watching the outcome. The state has now demonstrated both the willingness to act and the measurement method it will use: average throttling depth and how quickly it kicks in.

The case now moves toward resolution, with the precedent clear that New York intends to police the affordability terms of its broadband law household by household.

Also reported

Original: governor.ny.gov

Share this article:

« Previous

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

514 articles

New York Enforces Affordable Broadband Act Against T-Mobile — Telecom Gazette