Spectrum & PolicySouth AfricaWoanIcasaSpectrum Policy

South Africa kills off the WOAN after seven idle years

South Africa's minister Solly Malatsi has withdrawn spectrum reserved for a wholesale open access network since 2019, returning 700-3500 MHz bands to ICASA after seven years without a licence.

4 min read

South Africa confirms the end of the WOANSpectrum & Policy
South Africa confirms the end of the WOANNel_Botha / pixabay

Why it matters

  • South Africa withdrew spectrum reserved for a WOAN in the 700, 800, 2600 and 3500 MHz bands, effective 25 September.
  • The 2019 policy produced no WOAN licence in more than seven years; ICASA auctioned the non-reserved spectrum four years ago.
  • Rwanda's wholesale network hit only 30 per cent population coverage by mid-2016 against a 95 per cent three-year target; its exclusivity ended in June 2023.
  • ICASA aims to grow assignable broadband spectrum from 850 MHz to at least 18,588 MHz by 2030, with deployment after 2028 for ten studied bands.
  • Ghana abandoned its wholesale 5G network plan earlier this year in favour of a multiband auction.

The story

South Africa has cancelled the reservation of spectrum for a wholesale open access network (WOAN), ending a policy that ran for more than seven years without producing a licence. Minister of Communications and Digital Technologies Solly Malatsi withdrew the 2019 directive that would have forced the regulator ICASA to issue the network a licence, and an amendment took effect on 25 September.

The decision returns spectrum in the 700, 800, 2600 and 3500 MHz bands to ICASA, which will now decide its fate. The bands have sat largely idle since the reservation was made, even though ICASA auctioned the non-reserved portions of the same bands four years ago.

What was the WOAN supposed to do?

The concept called for a consortium to build a single network and resell high-demand spectrum to operators on a wholesale basis. The government hoped this would foster competition and cut prices in a market long criticised for high data costs.

It never came close to reality. "The proposal to reserve high demand spectrum for prior assignment to a single wireless open access network has not resulted in the licensing of a WOAN in the more than seven years since this Policy was first issued, and the spectrum identified for that purpose has remained substantially unassigned," the amendment stated. The Minister concluded the continued reservation "is no longer justified".

What happens to the freed spectrum?

ICASA published an updated mobile (IMT) spectrum roadmap earlier this year. Of 1,155 MHz identified for IMT in South Africa, only 794 MHz has been assigned. The roadmap flags a further 1,145 MHz of mid-band spectrum under feasibility study, and ICASA aims to expand broadband spectrum available for assignment from the current 850 MHz to at least 18,588 MHz by 2030.

The authority has published feasibility studies for ten bands and is drafting radio frequency spectrum assignment plans, targeting deployment after 2028:

  • 1710-2200 MHz
  • 1880-1920 MHz
  • 3600-3800 MHz
  • 4800-4990 MHz
  • 6425-7125 MHz
  • 24.24-27.5 GHz
  • 37-43.5 GHz
  • 45.5-47 GHz
  • 47.2-48.2 GHz
  • 66-71 GHz

The comment deadline for the roadmap closed on 30 October.

Why did the plan fail?

The WOAN's decline was slow rather than sudden. ICASA first invited applications for WOAN spectrum in 2020, then suspended the licensing timeline in November 2021. Many observers read that as the end. Instead, government considered handing the spectrum to a proposed State Digital Infrastructure Company combining Sentech, the state signal distributor, and Broadband Infraco, the state telecoms infrastructure firm.

"This plan has come to a halt for now due to the dismal financial situation Broadband Infraco finds itself in," said Dobek Pater of consultancy Africa Analysis. "As often happens with decisions in South Africa, the government 'sat' on it, without progressing either way."

Pater called the WOAN ill-conceived from the start. "None of the examples from around the world has worked to date," he said, citing doubts about the ownership model, the operating model and the ability to fund a national network build. The GSMA reached a similar verdict in a January 2024 report: single wholesale networks "have not proved successful to date and the plans have largely been abandoned for competition-based approaches".

Do wholesale networks work anywhere?

Regional precedent lent little comfort. Rwanda's wholesale network reached only about 30 per cent population coverage by mid-2016 against a 95 per cent three-year target; after coverage goals were eventually met, take-up stayed low, and in June 2023 the regulator removed the operator's exclusivity for 4G LTE and beyond. Ghana abandoned its wholesale 5G network plan earlier this year after barely a year, opting for a multiband auction.

South Africa itself shows wholesale models can emerge without mandates. Comsol recently launched a wholesale 5G network in Gauteng with national ambitions, and a UK- and South African government-backed project in KwaZulu-Natal uses a WOAN-style model to share infrastructure in townships and rural areas.

Pater argued the 2022 auction's requirement that bidders host a defined number of MVNOs is already expanding that market. "If there is a business case for one, the private sector will certainly address such an opportunity," he said, adding that properly regulating sustainable existing operators makes more sense than creating new ones that may fail. With the reservation withdrawn, attention now shifts to ICASA and how quickly it can move the returned bands into the roadmap's post-2028 deployment pipeline.

Also reported

Original: gov.za

Share this article:

« PreviousNext »

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

514 articles