Spectrum & Policy2 Ghz SpectrumMobile Satellite ServicesSpacexEuropean Parliament

EU Parliament Committee Blocks SpaceX's 2 GHz Path by 56 Votes to 14

ITRE voted 56-14 to keep the Commission's 2 GHz MSS plan, capping financial bids at 5% and adding EU data and control rules that block SpaceX's EchoStar route.

4 min read

European Parliament backs Commission’s plan for 2 GHz MSS bandSpectrum & Policy
European Parliament backs Commission’s plan for 2 GHz MSS bandFabian Kleiser / unsplash

Why it matters

  • ITRE backed the Commission plan 56 votes to 14.
  • Financial bid capped at five per cent of selection weighting; full population and land coverage required within 10 years.
  • SpaceX's EchoStar deal covers 2 x 15 MHz but the open-category cap is 10 MHz per applicant.
  • Consortia allowed via joint venture; Deutsche Telekom, Orange, Telefónica and Vodafone qualify as Union new entrants.
  • Council general approach targeted by end-2026; trilogues likely to start in 2027.

The story

The European Parliament's industry committee has voted 56 to 14 to reserve most of the 2 GHz mobile satellite services (MSS) band for European operators, backing the European Commission's plan and, in its current form, closing SpaceX's most direct route into the spectrum.

ITRE adopted a single compromise text covering the whole proposal on Tuesday. Counterproposals from the Greens — to extend the regulation to all MSS bands and replace the comparative selection with an auction — and from the ECR, which wanted authorisation handed back to member states, were never put to a vote.

The committee kept the Commission's core architecture intact. The band is divided into six paired 5 MHz blocks: two for a secure governmental MSS/hybrid system that must be EU-owned or EU-controlled, and four for commercial use, shared between EU-based new entrants and an open category in which non-EU operators may compete. The 2 x 10 MHz cap per commercial applicant and the 20-year licence term, renewable once, remain unchanged.

Where did MEPs intervene?

The changes sit in the detail. The one-off financial bid may now count for no more than five per cent of the selection weighting. Coverage obligations extend to full population and land coverage within 10 years, on top of the existing 95% and 90% five-year targets. The call for applications must be issued by delegated act within 12 months of entry into force, after a public consultation and an opinion from the Radio Spectrum Policy Group.

For SpaceX, the arithmetic is unfavourable. EchoStar has agreed to sell its international 2 GHz rights, including 2 x 15 MHz in Europe, to SpaceX. As a US-controlled company, SpaceX could compete only in the open category, where the 10 MHz cap limits it to two-thirds of EchoStar's current holding. A new amendment suggesting applicants from the UK, the EEA EFTA states — Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway — and qualifying candidate countries "might be prioritised" for those blocks could squeeze SpaceX further, although the text still describes the blocks as open to any third-country applicant.

The five per cent cap on the financial bid also removes SpaceX's ability to lean on its balance sheet. The text weights selection towards EU industrial added value, manufacture of key components in the EU and contribution to the European space ecosystem. A successful third-country-controlled bidder would have to process and store customer data within the EU, hold the encryption keys there and land all EU traffic "only" within Union territory.

Sovereignty drove several MEPs. Before the vote, Yvan Verougstraete, a Belgian MEP for Les Engagés, wrote that Europe "no longer wants to let Musk rule in space".

"Today, our satellite communications depend on a few American giants like Starlink," he said. "In Ukraine, we've seen how it works: when a foreign company holds control, it can cut everything."

What does this change for European mobile operators?

The text also shapes the joint bid explored by Deutsche Telekom, Orange, Telefónica and Vodafone, which want to build the ground network, offer open wholesale access and pair with a satellite partner yet to be chosen. Several amendments help that consortium. Consortia are now explicitly allowed to apply, provided they form a joint venture. The new definition of a Union new entrant excludes only those holding rights under the 2008 Commission decision, so the four operators qualify while Viasat and EchoStar do not.

Control may now be exercised by EU-established companies, not just member states and nationals, and the selection criteria reward wholesale access on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms. The same consortium rules would suit SpaceRISE — the SES, Eutelsat and Hispasat grouping holding the IRIS² concession — for the governmental block.

Other amendments cut the other way. In the new-entrant category, control and jurisdiction tests apply to every consortium member, and a new provision requires the entrant to retain the ability to modify, upgrade and operate the system, "including its space segment and network control", free of third-country restrictions. That would be a problem if the operators team up with a US satellite partner such as AST SpaceMobile, with whom Vodafone already runs the SatCo joint venture. Vodafone's status as a UK company may also raise questions under the third-country control test, depending on how a joint venture is structured.

The European Council has yet to agree its position; the Irish Presidency is aiming for a general approach by the end of 2026. ITRE voted to open trilogue negotiations, with a team led by rapporteur Angelika Winzig of the EPP, and those talks are likely to start in 2027.

Also reported

Share this article:

« Previous

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

565 articles