Spectrum & Policy4ghz SpectrumSpectrum PolicySpectrum SharingNtia

4GHz Band Emerges as Next US Spectrum Battleground

Valo Analytica, CTIA and NextG Alliance split on whether 4.4–4.94GHz should be auctioned exclusively or shared, as NTIA studies a band crowded with defense systems.

4 min read

4GHz is the next battleground for spectrum-sharingSpectrum & Policy
4GHz is the next battleground for spectrum-sharingTama66 / pixabay

Why it matters

  • US policymakers identified 4.4–4.94GHz for possible commercial use in the WFTCA and a December 2025 presidential memorandum on 6G
  • Valo Analytica proposes sharing based on CBRS, 6GHz AFC and 70/80/90GHz coordination models; CTIA backs clearing and auctioning exclusive national licenses
  • Apart from one Japanese network, only operators in China and Russia run high-power MNO deployments in the band
  • Allies including South Korea, Taiwan, Japan and European nations mainly use the n79 band for private 5G or military purposes
  • CTIA cites Accenture's early-2025 AI projections to justify spectrum demand, and pushes for global identification via CITEL and WRC-27

The story

Three newly published reports agree on one point: the US 4.4–4.94GHz band should carry commercial traffic. They disagree sharply on almost everything else, and the outcome of that dispute will shape how the next tranche of American 5G and 6G capacity gets licensed.

The band, currently occupied by numerous defense and other federal applications, has moved up the policy agenda fast. Both the Working Families Tax Cut Act (WFTCA, formerly OBBBA) and the December 2025 presidential memorandum on "Winning the 6G Race" explicitly named it as a candidate for commercial use. The NTIA has now begun formal studies of the band, and stakeholders are lining up with research to match.

The three key documents are:

  • A Valo Analytica report, "Sharing the 4GHz Band: Extending American Leadership in Spectrum Access," commissioned by Spectrum for the Future
  • A CTIA report, "Optimizing the 4GHz Band for America's Economic and National Security"
  • A NextG Alliance paper covering spectrum options for 6G more broadly

What do the reports actually say?

All three describe the incumbent federal services — point-to-point links, ship/shore and air/ground systems, and some known locations — subject to disclosure limits. They also flag aircraft altimeters below the band and public safety systems above it, which may need protection or guard bands.

Beyond that baseline, the divergence is stark. The Valo Analytica report is sharing-centric. It reviews publicly known usage systematically, suggests coexistence models for each category of incumbent, and does not sugar-coat the NTIA's likely finding that many federal systems will be difficult, slow and expensive to relocate and re-engineer. Its argument is that significant benefits are still achievable through sharing, avoiding onerous replacement cycles of reconfiguration, certification and testing.

It draws on past sharing successes as starting points: CBRS dynamic protection areas, 6GHz automated frequency coordination (AFC) and the "stoplight" coordination system for 70/80/90GHz. It also proposes low-power indoor use modeled on 6GHz Wi-Fi experience, with the caveat that 4GHz-specific protection studies would still be needed.

Where does CTIA's case fall short?

CTIA's document takes the traditional route: clearing entire sections of the band for auction and exclusive, high-power national licenses. It offers limited detail on the technical changes, disruption and costs beyond some point-to-point links, and leans on the argument that clearance could be quick because previous efforts such as AWS-3 proved easier than the most pessimistic forecasts.

One methodology deserves scrutiny. CTIA uses drive tests to show low measurable usage of the band in certain locations. But the proportion of time links are active does not establish their value — infrequent use by the Nuclear Emergency Support Team is a feature, not evidence of spare capacity. Drive tests are also poorly suited to characterizing airborne or maritime operations, directional links, or passive receivers needing protection.

CTIA's economic case rests on broad forecasts of AI's economic impact, citing Accenture's early-2025 projections. Those forecasts do not demonstrate incremental mobile traffic, let alone a need for nationwide exclusive spectrum. Most AI data traffic moves inside or between data centers and enterprise sites; factory robots and indoor automation arguably support local spectrum access rather than more high-power macro capacity.

The geopolitical framing is similarly thin. Apart from one network in Japan, the only known high-power MNO deployments in 4GHz are in China and Russia — the latter making the band the centerpiece of its 5G effort. Allies such as South Korea, Taiwan, Japan and European nations use the n79 band mostly for local private 5G or military purposes. CTIA's call for US support of global identification via CITEL and WRC-27 ignores the objections of allies whose defense systems occupy the band, and the complications NATO interoperability poses for a purely domestic clearance argument.

What should NTIA do?

The NextG Alliance paper sits between the two: it acknowledges sharing and repacking but prioritizes exclusive allocations, with sharing where clearance is infeasible. It skips local licensing, indoor wireless and private-network access in detail.

Both Valo and CTIA lean on AI-related use cases — Valo toward location-specific capacity at industrial sites, CTIA toward nationwide mobile operator deployments. Other candidate uses include drone control and telemetry from autonomous systems, defense-related AI and radar-like sensing, DOJ agency use beyond military bases, and new defense systems such as the Golden Dome anti-missile shield.

The consistent view across all three is that 4GHz presents a real commercial opportunity. Leaping straight to clearing and auctioning large exclusive blocks, however, is premature. Valo's report is the more rigorous: it counts net auction revenues after incumbent relocation costs rather than headline gross returns, and notes that "smaller-footprint geographical licenses" could be "economically attractive to a wide range of bidders."

The reasonable path is for NTIA to work system by system and sub-band by sub-band, without a presumption that clearance and national licenses are the best option — some cases may justify clearance, others repacking, others coordinated sharing. With NTIA's studies ongoing and WRC-27 on the horizon, that evaluation has a natural timeline to work against.

Also reported

Original: rcrwireless.com

Share this article:

« PreviousNext »

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Correspondent covering technology and product news in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

503 articles