Fiber & BroadbandRdofBeadRural BroadbandBroadband Subsidies
Phoenix Center: 70% of RDOF Subsidies Funded Broadband That Was Coming Anyway
A Phoenix Center study of $680 million in RDOF subsidies finds 70 percent funded deployment that would have happened anyway, buying roughly 10 months of acceleration per area.
Fiber & BroadbandWhy it matters
- Phoenix Center study finds ~70% of examined RDOF subsidies funded deployment that would have happened anyway.
- Of $680 million examined, about $480 million went toward accelerating deployment already on its way, at $172 per location per month.
- Funded areas reached 68% broadband availability by December 2025 versus 48% in unfunded areas.
- TPI's October study found RDOF subsidies caused only ~34% of availability gains and accelerated service by about four months per location.
- NTIA rejected nearly $4 million in proposed BEAD funding for Washington, D.C., in March over eligibility concerns.
The story
Roughly 70 percent of the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund subsidies examined in a new study paid for broadband deployment that would have happened without federal support, calling into question how effectively Washington spends money to close the digital divide.
The Phoenix Center for Advanced Legal & Economic Public Policy Studies released the analysis Tuesday in Washington. Chief Economist George Ford compared broadband availability in areas that kept RDOF funding against areas that lost it after the Federal Communications Commission rejected two of the auction's largest winning bidders, SpaceX and LTD Broadband.
That rejection created a natural experiment. Using availability data through December 2025, Ford estimated that only about 30 percent of deployment in the funded areas was attributable to the subsidies. The remaining 70 percent would have occurred regardless.
What did the money actually buy?
Of the $680 million examined, approximately $480 million went toward accelerating deployment that was already on its way, according to the study. The subsidies moved deployment forward by an average of about 10 months, at an estimated cost of $172 per location per month.
The comparison shows real but limited effects. Funded areas reached 68 percent broadband availability by December 2025, against 48 percent in areas that did not receive the funding.
The findings echo an October study by the Technology Policy Institute. In Already Being Built: What Rural Broadband Subsidies Paid For, 2018 to 2025, TPI President Scott Wallsten examined six federal and state broadband subsidy programs over seven years and found that subsidies generally paid for service already on its way rather than creating entirely new deployment.
For RDOF specifically, Wallsten estimated that subsidies caused about 34 percent of the increase in broadband availability, meaning roughly two-thirds of the gains would have occurred without the funding. His report also found that RDOF accelerated service by an average of 0.32 years, or about four months, per funded location.
Why the timing matters for BEAD
Both studies land as states continue working through implementation of the $42.45 billion Broadband Equity, Access and Deployment program, identifying locations eligible for federal support. Some states still face challenges moving infrastructure funding forward.
Federal officials have already encountered evidence that proposed projects do not always target places that need subsidies. In March, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration rejected nearly $4 million in proposed BEAD funding for Washington, D.C., after determining that the locations were already served or otherwise ineligible.
The two reports raise a central question for program design: whether federal broadband programs adequately distinguish between areas that need subsidies to attract private investment and those where providers are already likely to build on their own.
The issue will grow more pressing as BEAD, intended to extend high-speed internet to unserved and underserved communities, moves from planning to construction, with both studies suggesting that tighter targeting — not larger budgets — will determine how much new coverage each federal dollar actually produces.
Also reported
Original: phoenix-center.org
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.
535 articles