Spectrum & PolicyIndiaWebsite BlockingInternet RegulationContent Takedown
India Opens Inquiry After 129 Website Blocks Traced to Forged Court Orders
India's telecoms ministry blocked 129 betting sites on forged high court orders emailed by fraudsters, and police have sent 24 questions to the ministry.
Why it matters
- India's telecoms ministry directed ISPs to block 129 betting websites based on forged court orders in the names of the Rajasthan and Allahabad high courts.
- Police sent 24 questions to the ministry and requested its content management system logs as part of a criminal investigation.
- One forged document carried a fake court logo, seal and counterfeit QR code.
- The ministry plans to revoke the blocking directives and remove forged documents from its website.
- India's Supreme Court in July struck down a tribunal ruling based on non-existent judgments.
The story
India's telecoms ministry ordered internet providers to block 129 betting websites this year on the basis of court orders that were forged — and now it is investigating how that happened.
The inquiry, launched after a Reuters investigation published Wednesday, will examine the ministry's internal procedures and weigh additional verification checks before officials act on future takedown requests, a government official with direct knowledge of the matter said on Thursday. The forged orders were issued in the names of two state high courts — Rajasthan and Allahabad — and emailed to telecoms officials by alleged fraudsters posing as lawyers.
"It's serious … Maybe in future some genuine websites may also be blocked in the same manner," the official said, speaking on condition of anonymity.
What has been exposed so far?
The core facts are stark:
- The telecoms ministry, an arm of the government, directed internet providers to block 129 websites it labeled illegal betting platforms.
- The blocking directives rested on court orders that the Rajasthan and Allahabad high courts never issued.
- At least one document carried a fabricated court logo, a fake seal and a counterfeit QR code.
- As of Thursday, correspondence with the alleged fraudsters and copies of the forged orders were still visible on the ministry's own website.
The ministry did not respond to queries. That silence leaves open the most consequential question: who inside the takedown pipeline was supposed to authenticate the orders, and why did nobody do it before 129 sites went dark.
The official said the ministry is now trying to identify those behind the email addresses used to send the forged documents. It also plans to revoke the blocking directives issued on their basis and remove the related documents from its website — a cleanup that had not yet been completed as of Thursday.
What does the criminal investigation involve?
Police have opened a formal criminal case. Their entry point came from the Allahabad High Court itself: court checks found that one of the purported orders cited by the ministry had never been issued, according to police documents reviewed by Reuters.
Ghanshyam Yadav, a cybercrime official in Uttar Pradesh, said police have asked the telecoms ministry for details of its content management system and digital logs — the forensic trail that would show how the forged orders were processed and by whom.
Police have sent the ministry 24 questions. Yadav said the ministry's response would determine the next investigative steps. Until those answers arrive, the scale of the breach remains unknown: 129 blocked sites are documented, but whether other forged orders were acted upon is a question nobody has yet answered.
Why does this matter beyond India?
The case lands amid growing concern over fake and AI-generated legal material. India's Supreme Court in July struck down a tribunal ruling that relied on non-existent judgments. In June, a US judge disqualified lawyers over fabricated legal citations. The India episode adds a harder edge to that pattern: forged legal documents were not merely cited in proceedings — they triggered actual state enforcement against live websites.
Politicians and activists have already seized on the gap. Saket Gokhale, an opposition politician, wrote on X: "(Why did the) ministry not even bother to verify the so-called court order … Beyond scary."
That question cuts to the structural weakness the inquiry must address: India's content-takedown system ran, at least in this instance, without a working authentication layer between incoming court documents and enforcement against internet providers. The ministry's promised procedural review — and whether the additional checks it is considering would have caught a document with a fake logo, seal and QR code — is the test to watch.
Also reported
Source: dawn.com
More from Rebecca Stone
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.
521 articles