Fiber & BroadbandDocsis 4 050g PonHybrid Fiber CoaxCable Broadband

Dell'Oro questions cable's 3GHz DOCSIS path as 50G PON looms

Dell'Oro's Jeff Heynen doubts 3GHz DOCSIS will reach commercial networks before 2030, by which time 50G PON deployments could leave cable's 25G targets a generation behind.

3 min read

Cable's push to 3GHz might already be behind PON's speed curveFiber & Broadband
Cable's push to 3GHz might already be behind PON's speed curveJKimsey / pixabay

Why it matters

  • DOCSIS 4.0 Optional Annex targets 3GHz spectrum and 25 Gbit/s, up from today's 1.8GHz
  • Heynen does not expect 3GHz technology in commercial networks until beyond 2030
  • 50G PON is already being deployed in China; Dell'Oro sees cable investment continuing through at least 2028
  • Comcast, Charter/Spectrum and Mediacom lead early DOCSIS 4.0 rollouts
  • CPE suppliers face rising memory and component costs plus the FCC ban on new foreign-made routers

The story

DOCSIS 4.0 Optional Annex promises 3GHz of spectrum and speeds of 25 Gbit/s, but Dell'Oro Group analyst Jeff Heynen doubts the technology will reach commercial cable networks before 2030 — by which point fiber operators deploying 50G PON today in China could leave cable a full generation behind.

Heynen, VP of broadband access and home networking at Dell'Oro, laid out the argument in a recent blog post and expanded on it in the Signal Strength Podcast. His question is simple. What does 3GHz actually change for cable operators if PON reaches 50-Gig first?

His answer: possibly nothing. "50-Gig PON is starting to get deployed now – not so much in the Western markets, but certainly in China," Heynen explained. "By the end of this decade … operators will have already deployed at least 50-Gig-capable line cards and platforms and maybe they're putting in 10-Gig optics. If the goal of 3GHz is to get you to 25-Gig, is it worth it because you're already behind?"

Where does cable stand today?

Cable operators have four broad paths: extending DOCSIS 3.1 with DOCSIS 3.1+, moving to DOCSIS 4.0, pushing spectrum to 3GHz or even 6GHz, or overbuilding their most competitive markets with PON.

The rollout of DOCSIS 4.0 — which lifts spectrum from today's 1.8GHz state of the art toward 1.8GHz-plus plans — is in its early stages, led by Comcast, Charter Communications/Spectrum and Mediacom Communications. Many other operators remain focused on DOCSIS 3.1 mid-split and high-split upgrades that boost upstream speeds, plus DOCSIS 3.1+, which opens additional OFDM channels for a downstream gain.

What are the engineering obstacles?

DOCSIS 4.0 Optional Annex would extend the life of hybrid fiber/coax networks, but Heynen questions whether the economics will pencil out. The technology is immature. "Let's be honest. We're in the very early stages. We've got a long way to go," he said.

Getting to 3GHz also forces hard decisions about the outside plant: raising power levels at existing amplifiers or adding more active electronics to the network. Both raise cost and complexity.

One alternative Heynen raises is aiming higher — 6GHz and 50 Gbit/s over coax — which would at least match the headline speed of 50G PON.

Will operators stick with HFC or overbuild with PON?

Heynen believes financial pressures could persuade more operators to embrace DOCSIS 4.0 rather than fund more expensive PON overbuilds. But the decisive metric will not be speed. It will be subscriber gain and retention. If DOCSIS upgrades fuel stronger broadband subscriber growth, operators have a case for staying on the HFC path; if not, fiber overbuilds become more attractive despite higher costs.

He also flagged reliability as a competitive factor now matching or exceeding raw "speeds and feeds" in importance to customers.

What is squeezing CPE suppliers?

Cable modem and gateway vendors face a cluster of pressures: broadband subscriber losses, uncertain timing of DOCSIS upgrades, surging memory prices and the FCC's ban on new foreign-made consumer routers.

"They're all being squeezed on the component side. And it's not just memory. It's capacitors. It's screws. It's everything," Heynen said.

The CPE business model is also shifting. More operators now buy direct from original design manufacturers with their own production, pressuring OEMs that lack manufacturing. Heynen still sees room for OEMs that can manage software integration and supply chains — capabilities some operators lack in-house. On the software side, Prpl is gaining traction with CPE manufacturers as a device management and analytics platform and is becoming a stronger competitor to RDK.

Despite the lumpiness, Dell'Oro expects cable's current broadband equipment investment cycle to continue through at least 2028, with low-Earth orbit satellite broadband emerging as an additional competitive force on the broader market.

Also reported

Original: delloro.com

Share this article:

« Previous

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.

510 articles