Video & BroadcastAnti PiracyEU CopyrightHosting ProvidersNotice And Takedown
AAPA urges EU to write 30-minute takedown into copyright law
AAPA's new position paper asks for 30-minute takedown of live pirated content, a Union-wide register of non-compliant hosting networks, and blocking backstops in every member state.
Video & BroadcastWhy it matters
- AAPA published a three-layer position paper on live broadcast piracy on November 18, 2026
- Layer A would oblige hosting providers to remove live pirated content within 30 minutes of a valid notice
- Layer B would create a live Union-wide register of hosting provider networks that persistently fail to act on notices
- Layer C would require a dynamic live blocking mechanism in every EU Member State, subject to a binding Union-level capability test
- The Commission's November 2025 assessment found Recommendation (EU) 2023/1018 had not delivered the improvement it sought
The story
By Rebecca Stone
AAPA, the Audiovisual Anti-Piracy Alliance, has put a hard number on the table for European policymakers: hosting providers should face a legal obligation to remove live pirated broadcast content within 30 minutes of a valid notice, according to the anti-piracy body's new position paper, published on November 18, 2026.
That deadline — roughly two-thirds of a football half — is the sharpest of three layers in a document that, on AAPA's own account, cannot work in pieces.
The paper revises the body's position in light of the European Commission's consultation on the review of EU copyright rules, updating a May 2026 submission to the Commission's Call for Evidence on that review. That earlier filing set out, AAPA says, "the ecosystem, the critical role of hosting providers and European ICT, and the regulatory gaps."
The document opens with a claim rather than a statistic: "Live broadcast piracy in Europe is growing, not receding," it asserts. The supporting evidence for that trend is the Commission's own November 2025 assessment of Recommendation (EU) 2023/1018, the EU framework on hosting providers' removal of illegal content, which found the recommendation "has not delivered the improvement it sought."
AAPA's conclusion from that verdict is blunt: "The sector has exhausted what voluntary engagement can achieve; legislation is now required."
What would the 30-minute takedown rule require?
Layer A is a binding notice-and-takedown obligation on hosting providers, operating at the speed of the event rather than the speed of a moderation queue. Under the proposal:
- Removal must happen "as near to immediately as is reasonably and/or technically achievable" and, in any event, within 30 minutes of a valid notice.
- "Stay-down" measures must be meaningful, with effective supervision of compliance.
- Sanctions must deter systematic non-compliance.
Who carries the consequence for ignoring notices?
Layer B adds the penalty AAPA says the current framework lacks: a competent authority would designate the networks of hosting providers that persistently fail to act on notices and whose networks are predominantly used for piracy and other illegal content.
Designations would go into a live, Union-wide register. Publication of an entry would trigger binding obligations on providers established in, or offering services in, the Union not to serve the designated operator in respect of those resources or carry traffic to them.
Why does every member state need a blocking backstop?
Layer C requires a dynamic live blocking mechanism in every Member State, built on common minimum principles and a binding capability test at Union level. Whatever institutional route a Member State chooses, the mechanism must add and update verified targets inside the live window, without a fresh application for each event or target, while preserving effective review and redress.
The logic, AAPA says, is one of dependency: "The three measures are cumulative, not alternatives." Untimely takedown needs a consequence; the consequence needs a defined standard of non-compliance to attach to; and both need a backstop. "Adopt one without the others and the problem stays where it is," the body warns.
What does the paper leave unanswered?\n
The load-bearing elements stay undefined, and AAPA does not fill them in. The document offers no measurement of live piracy volumes in Europe, no count of hosting providers that persistently ignore notices, and no estimate of what a 30-minute deadline would cost hosting providers to meet.
It also does not identify which authority would sit behind Layer B, how a "valid notice" would be verified, or how review and redress would work for a target blocked minutes after a broadcast begins.
The claim that voluntary engagement is exhausted is likewise asserted rather than evidenced. And the November 2025 finding sat on a recommendation — an advisory instrument, not a directive — so the document's core argument concerns that instrument's ceiling rather than proof of what a statutory regime would deliver.
Whether the layers travel depends on the consultation now running the review of EU copyright rules — the process that drew AAPA's May 2026 submission — and on how far policymakers are willing to go on timing and on penalties for non-compliance.
Also reported
Source: Advanced Television
More from Rebecca Stone
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in Carrier business, 5G and 6G, fiber and broadband at Telecom Gazette.
539 articles